Stars: Maria Bello, Aidan Quinn, Brian F. O’Byrne, Kirk Acevedo
Writer:
Alexandra Cunningham, based on the series created by Lynda LaPlante
Director:
Peter Berg
Network:
NBC, Thursdays @ 10 PM
Original Telecast:
September 22, 2011

Not many television police dramas, or even television non-police dramas, can live up to the legendary 1991 BBC PRIME SUSPECT. Written by Lynda LaPlante, the miniseries stars Helen Mirren as Jane Tennison, the first woman homicide detective on a small North England police detective squad, much to the displeasure of most of the men working with her, not to mention the woman-hating title character she doggedly pursues over four episodes. The brilliant original gave birth to a number of follow-up miniseries, likewise starring Mirren. Most of them were pretty terrific also.

There’s no shame in a new TV police detective drama, especially an American one, not being PRIME SUSPECT. To avoid comparison, even if a show has a main character who is the first woman on a particular police detective squad, all the series really has to do is not call itself PRIME SUSPECT. This brings us to NBC’s new police detective drama, entitled PRIME SUSPECT.

Maria Bello stars as Jane Timoney, a hard-working NYPD detective who has just been transferred to the homicide squad in a precinct new to her. Her new supervisor Kenny Rowe (Aidan Quinn) doesn’t seem such a bad guy, but most of her squad mates hate her even before one of their number drops dead and Jane gets his case. The dead man’s partner (Bryan F. O’Byrne) has particular animosity toward Jane, who is also trying to accommodate her boyfriend’s custodial issues with his ex-wife regarding their young daughter.

The procedural aspect of PRIME SUSPECT is reasonably good, though having Jane bond with the victim’s little boy is a bit much, as if to say, don’t worry, she’s still feminine. (The original PRIME SUSPECT didn’t give a toss whether Tennison appeared feminine or not.) The sexist hazing Jane endures at the precinct is somewhat over the top, though it reportedly will be toned down in future episodes.

Mainly, though, this PRIME SUSPECT wants us to like Jane, so she’s got some rough edges, but she’s within the comfort zone of what network television likes to present in a main character. This is entirely at odds with the original PRIME SUSPECT, where we respected (and even slightly feared) Tennison; we liked her because she was so ferocious. Not that this PRIME SUSPECT should strive to recreate this in Jane Timoney – what worked in one country and decade is likely not to work in another. However, there doesn’t seem to be any real risk-taking at all here, and that is where the invited comparison really hurts the new edition.

Bellois a fine actress and gives Jane depth, intelligence and warmth. The show is a good vehicle for her and there’s no reason to suppose it won’t be a decent procedural from week to week. It’s just that, based on the pilot, it doesn’t have the essential elements that we associate with the title PRIME SUSPECT.

AGREE? DISAGREE? LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK – COMMENT BELOW!

Follow us on Twitter at ASSIGNMENT X
Fan us on Facebook at ASSIGNMENTX

 Article Source: Assignment X
Article: TV Review – PRIME SUSPECT – Season 1 premiere

 

Related Posts:

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Comments:

  1. I think it will fare very well. Pilots are tough having to introduce so many characters. So nice to see Kirk Acevedo on screen again. And Aidan Quinn is always spot on. Brian O’Byrne is aptly cast as the attitudinal bad egg and Maria is a perfect center. I liked her more than I thought I would.

    BarryShein
  2. Wife and I just watched about 10 minutes and switched shows. Loud music, hard-to-hear dialogue – whole approach seemed too contrived. I need a plot, not just New-York-ese give and take. Give me CSI or Law and Order or one of the other new shows. I just deleted this one from my DVR series recording. Now on to Blue Bloods or…

    Hank Whitney
  3. Loved the original. Love this one. I was worried that PS would be ruined by American TV, but, that certainly isn’t the case. It’s been eons since the British version was televised, so I’m surprised by the characters who have translated to the American version—and the quirks that Timony displays. I liked the pilot, and I liked the second episode.

    max
  4. Love it. I loved Prime Suspect with Mirren. Not looking for this show to be that show. Jane is one tough woman who has great instincts and she is wonderful to watch – Bello is fantastic – one of the best actresses out there. Whether or not the show is realistic representation of homicide police dept? I could care less. Please give this show a chance. I am already hooked.

    Karen
  5. Have just seen the first show in Australia – very raw – just loved it. Desperate to know who plays the background music for the show

    BRUCE
    • Sounds a lot like Mel Sachter, bass player for original Grand Funk Railroad to me. Anyone know for sure? It ROCKS!!!!!

      steve
  6. Bello is perfect. But I think the Keystone cops are back, just too many blunders.

    Judith
  7. Just watched the pilot. I agree with the “B” so far. It is NOT the “Prime Suspect” of Mirren’s world. I thought the dialogue was very hard to follow (hear) in the beginning. Quinn and O’Byrne were fine. Hated the boyfriend complication, and scenes dealing with his kid. Unlikely to stay with this show.

    John Yogis
  8. This is no imitation of the real Prime Suspect. I think the British should sue. The writing is so predicable and the characters so stereotypical of stupid American cops, I’m sympathetic for the actors who are forced to perform such tripe. Went back to my PVR and erased all episodes.

    Keith McEwen

Leave a Comment

CAPTCHA Image
*

Increase your website traffic with Attracta.com
bottom round